I was about to deliver a presentation at the annual media conference Splice Beta on Wednesday when Trump’s votes edged toward 270. For hours, I tireless refreshed election coverage on the New York Times, which, weirdly, took away some of my stage fright. It didn’t hit me until right before the presentation that Trump was winning.
The shock felt familiar to me. In 2016, my heart dropped while working at the office. It may have been familiar to many of you, my beloved echo chamber.
My original intention for the post was to assess people’s reactions to Trump’s victory from different Chinese social platforms, as international media largely focuses on Beijing’s response. I will share those in part 2 tomorrow.
Liberal media’s failure
From media coverage to behind-the-door conversations with people close to Washington, all indicators in my circle pointed to Harris. Although I had my worries in the back of my mind, knowing that I was in my echo chamber with endless pages of 'Kamala IS brat' content.
After Trump’s first presidential victory in 2016, the US journalism industry had a collective reckoning that they had failed to tell the truth of the American people outside their bubbles. That remorse was something I lived and breathed in while at the J-school before Covid, it was the pretext of whatever lecture or talk I was in. I thought that liberal media had already learned their lessons, but even if they have, the execution was disappointing.
So, this feels like a continued failure of American journalism. As someone who was trained by the system, I want to ask, how do we find ourselves in this hole again? What new takeaways can we draw this time? Is media going to embrace another ‘Trump bump’now?
Supporting Trump policies VS Trump values
I’m not an American citizen, I can’t vote. But the Trump victory has everything to do with me. The country has been my spiritual beacon since I was little, its liberal ideals partially shaped my individualism worldview, and consequently, the focus of this very newsletter (the people!).
I don’t think all Trump voters are evil.
There are two groups from my perspective: the ones who have felt wronged by Democrats, the ones who feel unheard; they are perhaps making a self-serving choice because they felt like no one was looking out for them. However, there are also the powerful people and billionaires who wholeheartedly believe in Trump’s ideals and focus only on their personal gains.
With the same outcome, is there any difference?
Yes. Because the former choice was made out of necessity from their own perspective. You can’t ask them to care for abortion rights or climate change when they feel their day-to-day livelihood is on the line. I wish the media could shed more light on their struggles and give them more voices, I wish the Biden administration provided more support to them during his term.
For the latter group, I believe that their contribution to humanity is net freaking negative. Together with Trump, they are setting an example for the next generation — not just in the US but in the world — that it’s ok to disrespect women, it's ok to be racist, it’s ok to disregard climate change, among many other anti-human things.
I WORRY that Trump values (not Republican values) are going to persist and infiltrate all over the world. At this moment, if I were to temporarily think that being a misogynist and a racist doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things, I’d still be concerned about the climate.
In this regard, I can’t agree more with this Bloomberg op-ed title: “America deserves Donald Trump. The world doesn't.”
Takeaways for China watching?
What’s happened in the 2024 election serves a good lesson for China watching: What media reports on, and your English-speaking, liberal friends’ own political views may not be representative.
Not so long ago, I had a chat with a Chinese-learning American journalist friend on our outlook about China. I didn’t expect that I'm contributing to her imagined future as well — she’s hopeful, she said, because there are young Chinese people like me.
But, I told her, I’m painfully aware that there aren’t many people like me left in China. I could barely have a full conversation about social issues and politics outside my echo chamber. Whenever I go online to see how others react to certain topics, I feel so alone. (There are too many examples in tomorrow’s post that disappointed me.)
The Chinese people whom I feel frustrated with — for believing in conspiracies, supporting a China-Taiwan war, being anti-feminist to the level of being anti-female, etc. — are the majority and I am not. I also have no power to change the status quo. I may be the loudest in your echo chamber, because I speak the language you understand and I have a platform outside the Great Firewall, albeit a small one.
It’s devastating for me to think that they are heavily influenced by propaganda and conspiracies because they’re inside the Firewall, and they perhaps think I’m brainwashed by the West.
For China watchers or anyone, it’s dangerous when both the deliverers and recipients of information aren’t aware of the limitations of the information itself, and information channels through which it’s delivered. [To be continued.]


